Jill Dahrooge
Females are categorized
as being strong and powerful but in their own petite way. This stereotype has created the unhealthy
emphasis on how women need to be fit and skinny or else they are ostracized by
society. Courtney Martin shows this
problem by recording that 90% of high school girls think that they are overweight. Over half of these girls said that they would
rather be hit by a truck than be fat while 2/3 of these girls said they would
rather be stupid or mean ("Introduction" 221). The media has created this disturbing image
of the "perfect" body size that has mentally destroyed females. The need for a thin body has become the
ultimate goal for most women today even during pregnancy. While the articles "Past the Dedication
is Disease: Athletic Obsession" and "Getting Your Body Back" show
how destructive the media can be to women, they also portray the extreme confusion
that women face due to the contrasting advice to be extremely fit yet not masculine.
The article
"Past the Dedication is Disease: Athletic Obsession", Martin
describes the body image struggles that female athletes endure. The female athletes' body is constantly
scrutinized in the media because it is not feminine to have big, bulky bodies;
which is why many female athletes struggle with eating disorders. Inside girls locker rooms they are combing
their hair, making perfect braids and ponytails, complaining of pimples and
makeup, and grossing out over their dirty equipment (225). These images are most likely not seen in a
male locker room. Since sports
themselves are seen as a more masculine activity, women try hard to make
society not question their gender even though they are strong competitive
athletes. There is also a drive to
become better than the male athletes. The
dedication female athletes have (staying later after practice, dieting, running
extra miles before class and more) can become a disease. The need for females to show their feminine
empowerment and to have the perfect, skinny, athletic body that the media shows
as essential can corrupt the mental state of women. Female athletes contain the pressures from
coaches, families, society, and friends which can be harmful on their bodies.
You would
think, as Shari Dworkin and Faye Linda Wachs put it in "Getting Your Body
Back", that pregnancy "offers a unique opportunity for women to find
freedom from norms of physical containment" but it is the complete opposite (108). The importance of remaining physically fit
during pregnancy is said to be the number one goal of pregnant women. In earlier years doctors prescribed rest and
restrictions on physical activity, today physically activity is encouraged to
prepare yourself for the physical demands of labor. Exercise during pregnancy is said to ease the
pain and to help women return to their fit body after their pregnancy. There is also a sense of empowerment, similar
to the other articles, that women receive when exercising during pregnancy. They feel more confident and beautiful and
feel as if they are "winning" their deliveries (199). Women have the personalities that thrive off
of success. Dworkin and Wachs also write
that exercising while pregnant gives women control of their gender. Women are not seen as just "a baby
machine" by men but they are doing something for themselves (122). Instead of listening to men telling them to
sit down, women are doing the opposite. However,
this power is a feministic power. In
other words, these females may be gaining control of themselves and going
against men, but they are still doing it in a feminine way. Their exercises are paired with household
chores and with their baby; not masculine activities. Fashion advice for exercising outfits are
still given to pregnant women. While
exercising and empowerment is shown as important, it is still not acceptable
for women to be the stereotype of masculine.
What
surprised me is the fact that being pregnant is now seen as ugly. This takes away from the sole purpose of what
a pregnancy actually is and what is occurring in a women's body. It should be seen as a miracle, not a burden. Similar to athletics, sports should be played
for the shear enjoyment of participating in the game. The media has created too much emphasis on
the outward appearance of females which has taken away the main purposes for
these activities. Females have to worry
about being too masculine or not feminine enough, they can never just be
themselves.
Charlotte Sargent
ReplyDeleteJill makes a strong point when she says “what surprised me is the fact that being pregnant is now seen as ugly.” I had the same reaction as Jill, it is sad and unfortunate to think that being pregnant can be seen in a bad light or as something other than an amazing function of life. I can imagine it must be hard on pregnant women to see their bodies drastically change and not only that, their way of life and daily routine changes as well, but pregnancy should be seen as exciting and wonderful rather than women feeling double the amount of stress of really losing their bodies and worrying about getting them back once the pregnancy is over. However, exercise is encouraged these days, yet as Jill said, the exercises are done in feminine ways. Such as exercises that involve household chores or their exercises that include their baby; these are not masculine activities. Even though many pregnant women are not simply just resting, instead they are staying fit, which can be positive, it is still coming from the pressure in society to maintain a positive self-image. I have a feeling that many women who exercise during pregnancy are not just doing it to ease the delivery, but to maintain some sort of physical fitness and in order to not completely lose control of their body.
Lily Cannon
ReplyDeleteTo add on to what Jill and Charlotte having been discussing about pregnancy and beauty, I think its ridiculous to say a pregnant woman is at times considered “ugly”. My mother, tons of woman and men out there, and I believe pregnancy is beautiful. Walking around in public seeing pregnant woman I think its something to look up to at an appropriate age. When I’m on the beach and I see a pregnant woman wearing a bikini I don’t think or say “what the heck” but I admire her for having the guts to walk around with her stomach out. My mother had five kids, had always worn a bikini when pregnant on the beach, and embraced her pregnancy, which I believe people need to start doing.
Anna Grofik
ReplyDeleteAs Jill states, female athleticism can provide a sense of empowerment, but can also come with scrutiny of the body. I agree with Jill in saying that female athletes try hard to “make society not question their gender” because they are strong competitive athletes. The pressure to be both thin and athletic comes from a variety of sources and is majorly influenced by the desire to achieve self-validation and support from a coach, family members or peers.
Like Jill, before reading “Getting Your Body Back” I thought that pregnancy was a prime time to go against female physical containment and feel free from fitness expectations for once. However, this is apparently not acceptable. Prescribed workout routines during and after pregnancy are compared to actions ‘for the baby’ and for the mother’s self-esteem. The workout routines were laughably applicable to a certain type of woman; a woman who does not work and whose sole goals are to take care of her newborn, husband, and household chores. Throughout the entire article, the workout routines were basically comparable to single motherhood, in that the new mother was always expected to care for the baby, even if she wished to exercise.
I'm glad that Jill included Martin's comment about locker rooms in her blog post. When I was reading that section and specifically when I was reading about how the glitter from the cheerleaders never goes away, I saw my own high-school locker room. My school was incredibly small, and we didn't even have cheerleaders or lockers in our lockers rooms (how ironic is that?), but we did have the glitter problem. Athletic options for girls were limited because of our school's size, but many of us participated in soccer, basketball, and lacrosse anyways. These were considered the "athletic" sports compared to the "slacker" sports: ultimate Frisbee, tennis, kayaking. And yet, it was us athletic girls who went crazy over our appearance in the locker rooms and busses before games. We would tie maroon ribbons in our ponytails and put glitter all over. We would all shriek if we realized we hadn't shaved our legs the night before or left our back-up deodorant in our bags. Our main concern was less on the outcome of our games but instead our cute school spirit and hairless legs. I think this is fairly representative of high-school sports everywhere, and it definitely has something to do with the sexualization of female athletes. --Gracie Hall
ReplyDeleteKelsey Warkentin
ReplyDeleteJill's post included everything that I also found eye-opening reading this articles. One point I'd like to comment on was the pregnancy issue. I don't think it is that bad to exercise when pregnant. As long as the women aren't threatening the health of the baby and themselves, it's a perfectly normal thing to do. Pregnancy IS a beautiful thing and I can't wait to experience it, but I would still keep active during it. Even now when I don't work out for a couple days I feel lazy. What I do agree with was how the article was saying women were getting out of hand with it and letting it consume them. That is when it turns obsessive. Another aspect of Jill's post that I liked was the locker room and how female athletes try to make themselves less masculine. Since I'm a dancer (which is probably the girliest activity there is), I had never experienced that. But I do remember the cheerleaders in my school having sequined spandex or the lacrosse players wearing bows and vineyard vines sweatshirts on game days. I never thought that to be those girls feminizing themselves, but it's apparent now that that is exactly what they were doing.
Jill points out in her post how girls are consumed by their weight and their body image. She mentioned how 90 percent of girls think that they are overweight. I was shocked at how high this percent is. I know that it is typical for girls to have body image issues, but I didn't expect the percent to be this high. I also found it interesting when Jill described what girls do in the locker rooms. I am sure that guys do not scrutinize their physical appearance in fron of their teammates. And I am sure that they certainly do not spend time infront of the mirrors making sure that they look good enough to go out and get sweaty. Another point that Jill stated is how women feel empowered by being fit and busy. Women feel like they are "taking control" by being active and fit. It is a strange concept, but it makes sense. If women desire to be thin, then I guess they are taking control of what they want by being active and on the go
ReplyDeleteI agree with Jill that thinking pregnancy is ugly is ridiculous and something that I have never even thought of. Worrying about being fit is ridiculous especially when it is endangering the baby. I never thought of women having this problem and it is a scary thought that a pregnant womens appearance is important when they are supporting another life.
ReplyDeleteTJ
Delete