“The Beauty Myth” and “Hair Matters”- Lily Cannon
In
the article “The Beauty Myth” by Naomi Wolf, the idea of beauty was discussed
and it was explained how the definition of beauty has changed over the centuries
along with the changes in the roles of women.
Throughout
the article Wolf compared women today versus women years ago. She explains that
in the past, women were more interested in political issues, such as the right
to vote, whereas today, women are more focused on their appearance than in
taking an active role in social changes. Today women of all ages are focusing
on their weight. Wolf states, “thirty-three thousand American women told
researchers that they would rather lose ten to fifteen pounds than achieve any
other goal.” I believe that those in the media are the ones to blame. Flipping
through magazines today, you see women skin and bones, which causes society to
think that that is what women should essentially look like, thus making women
all around the world go to extremes to look that way. Not only does the rate of eating disorders go
up, but the rate of plastic surgery does as well. This is because, as stated in
the article, “strong men battle for beautiful women”. The pressure for women to
look good in our society has increased, while the pressure for women to try to
be active in social matters has gone down. This should not be the case at all.
It seems to me that we are going backwards in the desire to make woman more
equal when it comes time to compare men and women. Society needs to stop
judging women by their appearance but by what they accomplish in the work
field, in school, athletic wise, etc. For example, in the movie “Devil Wears
Prada”, Ann Hathaway’s character is judged based on her unkempt appearance and
not on her intelligence.
Connecting
to “The Beauty Myth”, “Hair Matters”, by Ingrid Banks, also discusses the
matters of appearance, but more on the topic of hair. Throughout this chapter,
she discusses different peoples’ opinions on hair and how women of color should
wear it; either let it be natural and “nappy” or tend to it. What I found
interesting was the comparing of men and women of color’s hair and how if a man
were to grow his hair out long or braid it, it wouldn’t make him seem feminine,
however if a women were to cut her hair or shave it then she would be looked at
as a “dyke”. The example used in the text was Snoop Dogg, “When Snoop appeared
on the MTV Music Awards show in New York City a few years ago, his hair was
freshly straightened with lots of ‘Shirley Temple’ curls. A year or two later,
he was on the same awards show with straightened hair that touched his
shoulders. Despite Snoops hairstyling practices that imitate popular
hairstyling practices by (black) women, his ‘manhood’ and sexuality are not
called into question.” Although I agree with not judging a man based off his
hair, in this example I believe that women should be treated this way as well.
If women were to cut their hair short or shave it, as said before, they would
be looked at as a lesbian, which I believe is ridiculous. Banks describes that
having long hair is more attractive and makes you come off more appealing. This
reminded me of a time where I wanted to get a short bob but my mother, along
with my sister, told me how I should never do that because she loves my long
hair. Another example of family
commentary would be Kai (from “Hair Matters) and her father’s opinion and
decision-making on how she should do her hair, “ Like my father will not allow
[me to relax my hair]. He’ll get really upset [if I bring it up].” This just proves that your family, like
society, has an effect on your appearance, good or bad.
Touching
back on the subject of how women with shorter hair are judged, this can be
compared to females and their hair all over the country. Two summers ago I
traveled to Ghana for a mission trip and learned quickly that in most of the
schools I volunteered at, all girls (and boys included) had to shave their
head. This was a sense of equality and also hygiene. The equality between boys
and girls in Ghana was illustrated further by their similar expectations. For
example, in United States it is more acceptable for girls to cry than boys,
however in Ghana if a teacher where to find a little girl crying it would be
just as unacceptable as if a boy were crying here. The
discrimination of women and the way society judges us should change as a whole.
The Snoop Dogg example also really stuck out to me. In many public appearances Snoop Dogg has worn his hair in many "feminine" styles but no one has seemed to ridicule them. This reminds me of the recent "hair scandal" Miley Cyrus had a month ago. She posted pictures of herself on twitter of a new extremely short, partly shaved, and platinum blonde haircut. So many attacks were made about Miley's new hair and her sexuality and even mental health. I think that the time period of both Snoop Dogg and Miley Cyrus's hairstyles is the reason for the completely opposite public reactions. Snoop Dogg has always had long braided hair since he was famous in the 90s. Even today people would not comment on his looks because that's how he has always appeared to the public and it was very acceptable. Differently, Miley's hair brought up a lot of negative attention because of the judgmental world we live in. Appearance is a lot more important now than it was in the 90s. The reasons for this is unknown but I agree with Lily, these degrading opinions need to end. The media is corrupting people's viewpoints on appearance and it will only get worse if the issue is not taken care of soon.
ReplyDeleteJill Dahrooge
Like jill, the snoop dogg reference was very interesting, being that snoop was and still is a very recognizable figure in the fashion and music world that was a very interesting connection. from the time who i knew who snoop was i have seen him sport many different hair styles and personally i have never questioned him. i think this can be in part to its his personality. if this is the case then why should men and women be ridiculed for having a hair style that "should be for the other gender" if its part of their personality? Lilly keyed on a very good connection between the article and the world because snoops social status. that people of all ages would recognize. i also found it interesting that you went to Ghana and were able to use your experience there to help develop your argument about gender in our society.
ReplyDeleteJane Vinocur
ReplyDeleteI think the movie "The Devil Wears Prada" was a great example that Lily used to show how women are judged based on appearance far more often than men are. As Lily mentioned, in the past women were more focused on political and social changes, rather than changes in appearance. Obviously there have been changes in the past about appearance, but these changes were liberating - it became socially acceptable for women to wear pants, women gained more freedom over what to do with their hair, makeup, and just what to wear in general - whereas today, women's choices on appearance are restricting. What fashion choices women make instantaneously puts them into a category – rich, poor, straight, gay, hipster, sexy, conservative, etc. Women have gained so much social wise that it makes a little bit of sense that at this point their concern with something so meaningless as fashion becomes extremely meaningful – women don’t have to be as concerned with female-orientated social change as much today as in the past, so instead they focus meticulously on their appearance, because as Lily pointed out, magazines and media reinforce that they have to. The ideal woman has a successful career, a great, handsome, successful husband, and responsible, smart, beautiful children, and she dresses perfectly, in all the right brands and all the right styles. I agree with Lily that women have to be judged more on their intelligence like men are, and less on their appearance.
Lilly brings up many intriguing points in her post. For instance, she states that media is to blame for the way women perceive the ideal body and I completely agree with this. Wolf notes that women in the past eras felt little to no competition in regards to physical appearance because they were not exposed to magazines filled with models, but instead they were only exposed to woman in their surrounding areas. In addition to this, I also somewhat agree that the modern woman faces less pressure to be active in social matters. I believe that in certain areas around the world this is the case, but growing up in Kuwait –where woman could not vote until 2005- has allowed me to have a different view. It seems that in countries where women have less rights than the US or many EU nations, women face pressure to be apart of social matters because they still have not won the fight. The female Saudi’s I have met are some of the most ardent believers of equality because equality amongst the genders there is nonexistent.
ReplyDeleteLilly brings up many intriguing points in her post. For instance, she states that media is to blame for the way women perceive the ideal body and I completely agree with this. Wolf notes that women in the past eras felt little to no competition in regards to physical appearance because they were not exposed to magazines filled with models, but instead they were only exposed to woman in their surrounding areas. In addition to this, I also somewhat agree that the modern woman faces less pressure to be active in social matters. I believe that in certain areas around the world this is the case, but growing up in Kuwait –where woman could not vote until 2005- has allowed me to have a different view. It seems that in countries where women have less rights than the US or many EU nations, women face pressure to be apart of social matters because they still have not won the fight. The female Saudi’s I have met are some of the most ardent believers of equality because equality amongst the genders there is nonexistent.
ReplyDeleteZeina Jabali
I think we all agree that beauty ideals now a day are extremely irealistic and are driving women insane and self conscious to an extreme about how they should or should not look. Yes we need to blame the media for it, but we are forgetting that some of the most admirable women now a days, the ones who actually get the most focus from the media are not the starving models, but women who have an important role in our society. Look at someone like Dilma, Brazil's president, she was the first women ever elected as a president, and so far has done a much better job than the men who was president before her. If we look at these actual powerful and influential women, we will see that the looks do not matter so much for them. They got where they did because they don't let men intimidate them.
ReplyDeleteIf we look at the case of the Devil Wear's Prada that Lily pointed out, the most powerful person in that movie is Miranda. Yes, she is beautiful, and she cares about looks quite a lot, but if we actually analyze why she is powerful, we will notice that it is due her will power, and her courage of standing up before men, and not letting anyone intimidate her.