Monday, September 17, 2012


Sarah Wills, The Beauty Myth and Hair Matters Response
Beauty may only seem skin deep, but it has ability to over power women in Society. Both The Beauty Myth and Hair Matters stress importance of women’s appearances.
The article The Beauty Myth discusses the change of women’s role in society overtime. It is obvious that modern day women have significantly more power than woman from the past century. However, the need to be beautiful restrains women from being completely liberated. In the Early 20th century, women had significantly less power than men than they do now. Despite the newly achieved freedoms, women are still inferior when it comes to appearances. The influence of beauty on women is paralyzing. As Wolf points out, eating disorders and cosmetic surgery are on the rise. Pornography has also become more mainstreamed. This is all due to the fact that women need to be beautiful. In this society, beauty is portrayed as youthful, gaunt women. Huge industries have resulted from the need for women to be beautiful. Wolf even states that we might be “worse off than our unliberated grandmothers”. 

Why does beauty have so much power over women nowadays? Wolf describes beauty as “woman must want to embody it and men must want to possess women who embody it”.  This description makes beauty sound like a tangible object that can be obtained by all. People have been socialized to think that beauty is a necessity to be successful and happy. Wolf even describes women as being trapped in their bodies.  I feel that women pressure themselves to feel beautiful all the time because their bodies are so sexualized by men. When women are getting ready to go out, they know that men will look at them and make mental judgments. This subliminal notion causes women to be constantly self-aware and always conscious of their appearance.

The reading Hair Matters describes the issues of the black culture when it comes to hair. The major question from the reading is: natural? Or not natural? This hair issue seems to create a divide among the black culture. Ingrid Banks interviews people about their stance on black women’s hair. One interviewee states that “nappy hair is a badge of shame”. This means that black women’s hair, in its natural state, is disempowering. Some of the interviewees believe that black people have a choice when it comes to wearing their hair. However, there are social ramifications that have huge impacts when it comes to these decisions. Semple describes these ramifications as “sexual…economic, cultural…”. Therefore, black women can make decisions about their hair, but they have to except the way the society will respond to the decision. I feel that society does put ridiculous emphasis on hair. Personally, I have always kept my hair long and refuse to cut it. There is something about long flowing hair that feels good for a girl. Since black women don’t natural have this type of hair, they are pressured to change it to be more feminine. I agree that women have the choice about whether they want to wear their hair natural or not. However, the consequences of these decisions definitely impact their status and general public opinions. Just as Banks describes it, women with short nappy hair are not seen as feminine as women with long flowing hair.
Both readings relay the importance of women’s appearances. Beauty affects women in ways that hinder their ability to be successful in life. It is an obstacle that over powers some women. As Banks states, I feel that the need to be beautiful is a fairly recent trend that can be debilitating for some women.

8 comments:

  1. Overall, I agree with all of Sarah's points. She brings up the most controversial issues within both of these readings. The quote that stood out to me the most was the one Sarah also wrote about, that women are “worse off than our unliberated grandmothers”. It is crazy to think that years ago women had barely any freedoms but today they have an unthinkable amount, yet the social expectations of women today is destroying them. If you ask any woman what she first thinks about in the morning it usually consists of "what will I wear today?", "how does my hair look?", "am I wearing enough makeup?", or "will people think I look pretty today?" None of their thoughts are about the opportunities they have been given over the years and how they are going to use these to succeed. It is sad to think that women's minds are so overly consumed with social expectations that they lose sight of what they have available to them and their freedoms become a secondary thought.
    This also relates to our class discussion on high heels last week. We said that heels make a women feel powerful but why? I think that if a woman believes that she looks feminine or appealing to the eye, she will have more confidence. This confidence can lead to success in a woman's life. This might sound ridiculous but, to me, I think it is true. On days I feel more comfortable and pretty I go out of my way to be more social or I speak more in class. The way women feel is completely based on our appearances and our comfortability with our style. Women should feel comfort no matter how they look but that is not the situation today.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Sarah’s statement about society’s emphasis on hair. Another point in the “Hair Matters” article that I found interesting was the relationship between hair length and femininity. Long hair is perceived as more feminine than short hair, which is often characterized as “butch” or more masculine. A woman’s hair “becomes the ultimate marker of both her womanhood and sexuality” (88). If a woman lacks long hair her femininity is questioned. Why has hair come to represent ideas about femininity or sexuality? I knew someone who cut all her hair off in solidarity with a friend who was diagnosed with cancer and to donate it to an organization that makes wigs for cancer patients. She faced some negativity, some jokingly some more serious, about what her new haircut said about her as a female and what it did to her physical appearance. I found it so weird that such a simple act of cutting your hair, especially under the circumstances she did it, could cause such assumptions and negativity.
    Sammy Secrist

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think that sarah brings up some really interesting points from these articles, even if they are the riskiest ones to bring up. When it comes to discussing these things, like womens liberations and femininity along with beauty and appearance, there is definitely a line that must be carefully walked. I can appreciate that she brought up the importance of hair in black culture and discussed how women could feel oppressed by society if their hair was nappy and not neat.

    Zael

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Sarah states that woman dress up and look nice because they know they will be noticed by men. I disagree with this statement; I believe that women do all of this for themselves. Dressing up and feeling beautiful gives us confidence, which is why we go through all the charades. Although society does view certain styles differently, I agree with Sarah and Banks in that woman should style their hair in whatever manner they feel comfortable in. Women today find confidence in their material self, in that they rely too heavily on makeup and other material things rather than seeing the beauty in their naturalness. I believe in comfort and the beauty that comes with being natural.

    Zeina Jabali

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think Sarah talked about some very interesting points here, but something that I have to agree that she pointed out is what Wolf said, that women are trapped in their own bodies. As women we are constantly paranoid of how we talk, walk, how we look and even eat. The media has been bringing more and more attention to what an attractive women should look like, and focusing on making us believe that that attractive woman is the only one who will be successful and the one who men will seek for when looking for a partner.

    Aline

    ReplyDelete